The silent page awaits the waking dawn.The silent page awaits the waking dawn.
Comparison
Overcast·平静121reads
“Look how Zhang San’s kid studies without being told.” “Look how thoughtful Li Si’s girlfriend/boyfriend is.” … We all hate comparisons like these: they’re harsh on others and hurt people without doing anyone any good. I used to think I’d never say anything like that. When I was little, I often heard a close friend’s mom put him down this way, and it grated on me too. I quietly swore I’d never talk to anyone like that. But recently I said something like this to Xiao Liang. It really was hurtful. The words came out before I’d thought them through, and I regretted them immediately. Saying it wasn’t going to change anything anyway. So why did I say it?
So you must be unhappy with him, look down on him, and want to get under his skin?
Yes and no. Not saying it out loud doesn’t mean I’m not making the comparison in my head. I’d already weighed things up inside; the words were just ripples on the surface. So there’s no escaping comparison. Both the person making the comparison and the person being compared need to acknowledge that it’s there.
Now, though, I actually think saying it out loud was the right thing to do.
Thinking about this has given me a little more insight into the three-part formula from the Diamond Sutra that Wang Defeng talks about.
There’s no escaping comparison
Plato gives an example in the Phaedo: Socrates gets Simmias to agree that two sticks are never truly “equal.” He’s exploring how this intuition comes from the “soul” rather than experience, but here we could also understand “soul” as an idea of “equality itself” that’s already in our minds. However equal two real sticks might be, there’s always some difference. All our efforts only bring us closer to that ideal. The Seventh Letter, attributed to Plato, puts it plainly too: no circle we draw is the circle itself.
The first part of the formula goes: The Tathagata speaks of “comparison”—first, we have to acknowledge that comparison is there. It’s in everyone’s mind. We all have a yardstick.
When I was younger, I never got beyond this level: “I’m being compared” led to “I’m not as good as other people,” and that hurt. I’d heard other bits of wisdom too—nobody’s perfect, accept yourself, and so on—but I hadn’t connected them. One remark from someone else can’t invalidate everything about me. Being worse than someone at one thing is perfectly normal. So we do need to acknowledge that this “entity” exists. That helps when we encounter views that differ from ours, or even clash with them. It lets us take a more hopeful view and makes the next two parts easier to accept.
Neither side of a comparison is a fixed entity
Following the logic of the Diamond Sutra, we have to negate Plato’s theory of Forms—that perfect circle—too. Even a perfect circle is not, in itself, a circle; a “well-behaved child” is not, in themselves, a well-behaved child. The standard itself has no inherent nature either.
In a wedding speech, Professor Wang used the formula “The Tathagata speaks of spouses; they are not spouses; thus they are called spouses.” He explained that no two people are born spouses. When we compare, we’re always going to find a gap between the person and the ideal we have in mind, so we need to negate that notion right away. I think neither side of that “gap” has an inherent nature. Neither the real person nor the supposed ideal stays the same forever. Under the formula’s second part, “spouses” means “not non-spouses,” or “neither husband nor wife.” That’s pretty interesting: your partner can grow, or take a step backward. At 20, your ideal might be someone good-looking; at 30, someone intellectually sophisticated; at 40, someone with wealth and status; and at 50, you might be back to wanting good looks (laughs).
The second part of the formula: It is not “comparison”—we negate comparison, but the bigger point is not to get stuck on it. If neither side of a comparison is a fixed entity, then comparison itself isn’t one either. Without the A and B in A>B, the “>” has no meaning of its own.
Let life be “full” of comparisons
Relationship advice articles tell you, “Don’t compare your partner to other people,” then throw a bunch of reasons at you: it damages their self-esteem, you should love and support each other. Parenting books tell you, “Don’t compare your child to their siblings or classmates.” And we often hear the saying “Comparing yourself to others will only drive you mad”—a very plain expression of our fear of comparison.
The third part of the formula: Thus it is called “comparison”—looking at it now, I seem to be able to accept all of this. Comparisons already fill our lives. They start the moment we’re born: family, background, grades, schools, jobs, and so on. We can’t force other people to stop comparing us, either.
What we should really be thinking about in those examples is how we communicate comparisons and how we take them. The person making the comparison still needs to choose their words carefully. Going forward, I’ll try to do what Nonviolent Communication suggests: break a judgment down into observations, feelings, needs, and requests, and think before I speak. The person being compared doesn’t need to treat every comparison as an attack, either. In the story “Zou Ji Persuades the King of Qi to Accept Advice,” Zou Ji hears three different motives behind the same words, “You’re more handsome than Lord Xu”: his wife favors him, his concubine fears him, and his guest wants something from him. Listening to a comparison, he hears the motive, not just the conclusion.
There’s nothing wrong with saying a comparison out loud. If two people who love each other can still talk kindly afterward and work on what’s lacking, maybe that’s how they nurture the bond that makes them “spouses.”
Comparison
“Look how Zhang San’s kid studies without being told.” “Look how thoughtful Li Si’s girlfriend/boyfriend is.” … We all hate comparisons like these: they’re harsh on others and hurt people without doing anyone any good. I used to think I’d never say anything like that. When I was little, I often heard a close friend’s mom put him down this way, and it grated on me too. I quietly swore I’d never talk to anyone like that. But recently I said something like this to Xiao Liang. It really was hurtful. The words came out before I’d thought them through, and I regretted them immediately. Saying it wasn’t going to change anything anyway. So why did I say it?
So you must be unhappy with him, look down on him, and want to get under his skin?
Yes and no. Not saying it out loud doesn’t mean I’m not making the comparison in my head. I’d already weighed things up inside; the words were just ripples on the surface. So there’s no escaping comparison. Both the person making the comparison and the person being compared need to acknowledge that it’s there.
Now, though, I actually think saying it out loud was the right thing to do.
Thinking about this has given me a little more insight into the three-part formula from the Diamond Sutra that Wang Defeng talks about.
There’s no escaping comparison
Plato gives an example in the Phaedo: Socrates gets Simmias to agree that two sticks are never truly “equal.” He’s exploring how this intuition comes from the “soul” rather than experience, but here we could also understand “soul” as an idea of “equality itself” that’s already in our minds. However equal two real sticks might be, there’s always some difference. All our efforts only bring us closer to that ideal. The Seventh Letter, attributed to Plato, puts it plainly too: no circle we draw is the circle itself.
The first part of the formula goes: The Tathagata speaks of “comparison”—first, we have to acknowledge that comparison is there. It’s in everyone’s mind. We all have a yardstick.
When I was younger, I never got beyond this level: “I’m being compared” led to “I’m not as good as other people,” and that hurt. I’d heard other bits of wisdom too—nobody’s perfect, accept yourself, and so on—but I hadn’t connected them. One remark from someone else can’t invalidate everything about me. Being worse than someone at one thing is perfectly normal. So we do need to acknowledge that this “entity” exists. That helps when we encounter views that differ from ours, or even clash with them. It lets us take a more hopeful view and makes the next two parts easier to accept.
Neither side of a comparison is a fixed entity
Following the logic of the Diamond Sutra, we have to negate Plato’s theory of Forms—that perfect circle—too. Even a perfect circle is not, in itself, a circle; a “well-behaved child” is not, in themselves, a well-behaved child. The standard itself has no inherent nature either.
In a wedding speech, Professor Wang used the formula “The Tathagata speaks of spouses; they are not spouses; thus they are called spouses.” He explained that no two people are born spouses. When we compare, we’re always going to find a gap between the person and the ideal we have in mind, so we need to negate that notion right away. I think neither side of that “gap” has an inherent nature. Neither the real person nor the supposed ideal stays the same forever. Under the formula’s second part, “spouses” means “not non-spouses,” or “neither husband nor wife.” That’s pretty interesting: your partner can grow, or take a step backward. At 20, your ideal might be someone good-looking; at 30, someone intellectually sophisticated; at 40, someone with wealth and status; and at 50, you might be back to wanting good looks (laughs).
The second part of the formula: It is not “comparison”—we negate comparison, but the bigger point is not to get stuck on it. If neither side of a comparison is a fixed entity, then comparison itself isn’t one either. Without the A and B in A>B, the “>” has no meaning of its own.
Let life be “full” of comparisons
Relationship advice articles tell you, “Don’t compare your partner to other people,” then throw a bunch of reasons at you: it damages their self-esteem, you should love and support each other. Parenting books tell you, “Don’t compare your child to their siblings or classmates.” And we often hear the saying “Comparing yourself to others will only drive you mad”—a very plain expression of our fear of comparison.
The third part of the formula: Thus it is called “comparison”—looking at it now, I seem to be able to accept all of this. Comparisons already fill our lives. They start the moment we’re born: family, background, grades, schools, jobs, and so on. We can’t force other people to stop comparing us, either.
What we should really be thinking about in those examples is how we communicate comparisons and how we take them. The person making the comparison still needs to choose their words carefully. Going forward, I’ll try to do what Nonviolent Communication suggests: break a judgment down into observations, feelings, needs, and requests, and think before I speak. The person being compared doesn’t need to treat every comparison as an attack, either. In the story “Zou Ji Persuades the King of Qi to Accept Advice,” Zou Ji hears three different motives behind the same words, “You’re more handsome than Lord Xu”: his wife favors him, his concubine fears him, and his guest wants something from him. Listening to a comparison, he hears the motive, not just the conclusion.
There’s nothing wrong with saying a comparison out loud. If two people who love each other can still talk kindly afterward and work on what’s lacking, maybe that’s how they nurture the bond that makes them “spouses.”