The silent page awaits the waking dawn.The silent page awaits the waking dawn.
Thoughts on Being a Workhorse
179reads
Handmade
I read my friend SEISAMUSE’s article, # Why Are Workers Called “Workhorses”?, and found it really interesting. His questions offer an unusual take on the term, so I thought I’d follow his train of thought and see where it takes me.
What makes us workhorses turn to self-deprecation, loyalty, and hurting one another? Does self-deprecation defuse our discontent, or is it a form of resistance? How do we stop people at the bottom from hurting each other?
How We Become Workhorses
Are workhorses unable to get ahead because they’re loyal, or do they learn to be loyal because getting ahead is so hard? If they know that defying their owners or arguing with whoever holds the whip won’t meaningfully improve their situation, then “doing whatever you’re told,” “working diligently,” and “not talking back” aren’t necessarily signs of loyalty as a character trait—human or equine. They’re more likely survival strategies developed over a long series of power struggles.
Ask a workhorse why they don’t resist, and they’ll tell you to mind your own business and go to bed. What conditions gradually convince them that resistance isn’t worth it? I imagine their thinking goes something like this: I know I’m working hard, but I don’t believe hard work can fundamentally change my situation.
That makes this a little different from the belief that hard work pays off. Workers who bought into the American dream, or who benefited from the early years of the demographic dividend, would say:
“
I’m struggling now so I won’t have to struggle later.
And, like the heroine of Du Lala’s Promotion or the steel magnate # Andrew Carnegie, they really did make it.
But workhorses don’t buy that story. They say:
“
I’m struggling now because tomorrow will be more of the same.
So I’m inclined to think the taming of wild horses into workhorses starts very early.
When I visited the grasslands this August, I’d never ridden a horse, so I paid a few dozen yuan to give it a try. Unlike the other horses people were riding, mine had a foal following her:
As we made a lap around the grounds, the foal saw its mother moving and followed along. Halfway around, I saw another horse lying on the ground, barely alive. Its owner was crouched beside it, lighting a cigarette, with a phone loosely held in one hand. Maybe he was waiting for the vet. The person leading my horse said that horse probably wouldn’t last much longer. It had crashed into a railing the night before and injured its leg, or something like that. I didn’t dare imagine what the foal might think of the sight. Maybe it didn’t understand yet and only knew to follow its mother. But someday, without anyone teaching it, it might know that when a two-legged creature climbs on its back, it’s time to do a lap. I didn’t dare imagine what the horse beneath me was thinking, either. Maybe one day, if she couldn’t take it anymore, she’d make the same choice. For the rest of the lap, all I wanted was for it to be over.
Is Self-Deprecation Resistance, or Another Form of Taming?
It could be both. You could even argue that it doesn’t qualify as resistance at all.
On the one hand, calling ourselves “workhorses” is a self-deprecating attempt to “take apart” the solemn rhetoric of bosses, companies, and the system. Companies talk about “striving,” “mission,” “growth,” and “taking ownership.” In a government job, you might hear, “You should be grateful to your work unit for giving you stability.” But an employee saying, “Time for this workhorse to clock in,” brings that grand narrative right back down to the exchange of labor for pay.
On the other hand, being a “workhorse”—something that should be hard to accept—starts to feel perfectly normal once we’ve made enough memes about it. Think of the mare and foal I saw. The humiliation of having someone straddle your back, the numbness toward one of your own collapsing, the subjugation of the previous generation: all of that is grim enough already. If we then joke, “I’m just a workhorse,” to fit in or sound humble, that’s when the real tragedy becomes our own.
So why did I put “take apart” in quotation marks? Because calling ourselves “workhorses” doesn’t really take that rhetoric apart, either. In part four of his analysis of A Touch of Sin, video creator 金阁炎上 discusses how Xiaohui and Lianrong can come up with nothing but the online catchphrase “TMD”—roughly, “fuck”—when commenting on news about mining disasters and corruption. He explains it this way:
“
Xiaohui, too, has been castrated. Faced with “corruption” and a “mining disaster”—two different events, both directly relevant to his own life—he seems to have lost the ability to speak. He just keeps repeating clumsy internet memes and catchphrases. People like Xiaohui feel that social problems have no solution, so all they can do is vent through scattered bits of self-deprecating humor packaged as entertainment. And they still think what they’re saying is cool, “modern,” a sign that “everyone else is asleep, but I’m awake.” People no longer talk about mass movements or mention class struggle; organizing and solidarity can’t be spoken of. ‘When class disappears from our language, exploitation slips more easily into our lives; when history is softened into sentimental stories, the oppression we live with becomes easier to accept.’
“Just a workhorse with five days of annual leave, that’s all 😭” (my reply to a comment on my article # What I Photographed on My Trip to Gannan from SEISAMUSE). Using the “workhorse” meme and tacking on a trendy emoji—isn’t that another example of the impoverished language described above? Once a predicament becomes a meme, does it become easier to change, or just easier to endure? In my experience, unless we take another look at the language we use and examine ourselves, we’re more likely to keep enduring it and become like those two horses.
So that brings me to my third point: how to escape the workhorse trap.
Before We’ve Even Gotten Ahead, We’re Already Helping Crack the Whip
People at the bottom hurt one another every day, in our own lives and all around us. Security guards at residential complexes won’t let food delivery riders ride in to deliver orders. In the government bureaucracy, someone just one rank above you can make your life hell, pushing more work onto those below them and adding to the burden on frontline staff. This world really does run on a tightly written set of rules that controls who gets to move up while setting workhorses against one another.
Admitting we’re workhorses isn’t necessarily a bad thing, or something to be ashamed of. It means facing reality, and it’s also a prerequisite for criticizing the system. To borrow Mao’s theory: without being a workhorse, you have no firsthand experience; without firsthand experience, you have no right to speak.
One approach I can think of is to stop helping crack the whip first. Then we can examine ourselves, unpack other people’s language, and use clear words to bring more people together.
Take my own example: as one workhorse, I paid another—the riding stable’s owner—to lead (and, in effect, wield the whip over) the grown workhorse under his control and take me around in a circle. The little workhorse had to follow behind and learn, too. By giving up an activity that costs me money and makes me unhappy, I can avoid one more instance of workhorses tearing into each other. I’m writing this here in the hope that the next person who agrees with me might cancel their ticket to a dolphin show, press the button to let someone through their residential complex’s gate, or, if they’re a frontline supervisor, put a stop to some task that makes people miserable.
I hope we can be the good workhorses—the ones who treat other workhorses kindly and help them shed the label.
Thoughts on Being a Workhorse
I read my friend SEISAMUSE’s article, # Why Are Workers Called “Workhorses”?, and found it really interesting. His questions offer an unusual take on the term, so I thought I’d follow his train of thought and see where it takes me.
What makes us workhorses turn to self-deprecation, loyalty, and hurting one another? Does self-deprecation defuse our discontent, or is it a form of resistance? How do we stop people at the bottom from hurting each other?
How We Become Workhorses
Are workhorses unable to get ahead because they’re loyal, or do they learn to be loyal because getting ahead is so hard? If they know that defying their owners or arguing with whoever holds the whip won’t meaningfully improve their situation, then “doing whatever you’re told,” “working diligently,” and “not talking back” aren’t necessarily signs of loyalty as a character trait—human or equine. They’re more likely survival strategies developed over a long series of power struggles.
Ask a workhorse why they don’t resist, and they’ll tell you to mind your own business and go to bed. What conditions gradually convince them that resistance isn’t worth it? I imagine their thinking goes something like this: I know I’m working hard, but I don’t believe hard work can fundamentally change my situation.
That makes this a little different from the belief that hard work pays off. Workers who bought into the American dream, or who benefited from the early years of the demographic dividend, would say:
And, like the heroine of Du Lala’s Promotion or the steel magnate # Andrew Carnegie, they really did make it.
But workhorses don’t buy that story. They say:
So I’m inclined to think the taming of wild horses into workhorses starts very early.
When I visited the grasslands this August, I’d never ridden a horse, so I paid a few dozen yuan to give it a try. Unlike the other horses people were riding, mine had a foal following her:
As we made a lap around the grounds, the foal saw its mother moving and followed along. Halfway around, I saw another horse lying on the ground, barely alive. Its owner was crouched beside it, lighting a cigarette, with a phone loosely held in one hand. Maybe he was waiting for the vet. The person leading my horse said that horse probably wouldn’t last much longer. It had crashed into a railing the night before and injured its leg, or something like that. I didn’t dare imagine what the foal might think of the sight. Maybe it didn’t understand yet and only knew to follow its mother. But someday, without anyone teaching it, it might know that when a two-legged creature climbs on its back, it’s time to do a lap. I didn’t dare imagine what the horse beneath me was thinking, either. Maybe one day, if she couldn’t take it anymore, she’d make the same choice. For the rest of the lap, all I wanted was for it to be over.
Is Self-Deprecation Resistance, or Another Form of Taming?
It could be both. You could even argue that it doesn’t qualify as resistance at all.
On the one hand, calling ourselves “workhorses” is a self-deprecating attempt to “take apart” the solemn rhetoric of bosses, companies, and the system. Companies talk about “striving,” “mission,” “growth,” and “taking ownership.” In a government job, you might hear, “You should be grateful to your work unit for giving you stability.” But an employee saying, “Time for this workhorse to clock in,” brings that grand narrative right back down to the exchange of labor for pay.
On the other hand, being a “workhorse”—something that should be hard to accept—starts to feel perfectly normal once we’ve made enough memes about it. Think of the mare and foal I saw. The humiliation of having someone straddle your back, the numbness toward one of your own collapsing, the subjugation of the previous generation: all of that is grim enough already. If we then joke, “I’m just a workhorse,” to fit in or sound humble, that’s when the real tragedy becomes our own.
So why did I put “take apart” in quotation marks? Because calling ourselves “workhorses” doesn’t really take that rhetoric apart, either. In part four of his analysis of A Touch of Sin, video creator 金阁炎上 discusses how Xiaohui and Lianrong can come up with nothing but the online catchphrase “TMD”—roughly, “fuck”—when commenting on news about mining disasters and corruption. He explains it this way:
“Just a workhorse with five days of annual leave, that’s all 😭” (my reply to a comment on my article # What I Photographed on My Trip to Gannan from SEISAMUSE). Using the “workhorse” meme and tacking on a trendy emoji—isn’t that another example of the impoverished language described above? Once a predicament becomes a meme, does it become easier to change, or just easier to endure? In my experience, unless we take another look at the language we use and examine ourselves, we’re more likely to keep enduring it and become like those two horses.
So that brings me to my third point: how to escape the workhorse trap.
Before We’ve Even Gotten Ahead, We’re Already Helping Crack the Whip
People at the bottom hurt one another every day, in our own lives and all around us. Security guards at residential complexes won’t let food delivery riders ride in to deliver orders. In the government bureaucracy, someone just one rank above you can make your life hell, pushing more work onto those below them and adding to the burden on frontline staff. This world really does run on a tightly written set of rules that controls who gets to move up while setting workhorses against one another.
Admitting we’re workhorses isn’t necessarily a bad thing, or something to be ashamed of. It means facing reality, and it’s also a prerequisite for criticizing the system. To borrow Mao’s theory: without being a workhorse, you have no firsthand experience; without firsthand experience, you have no right to speak.
One approach I can think of is to stop helping crack the whip first. Then we can examine ourselves, unpack other people’s language, and use clear words to bring more people together.
Take my own example: as one workhorse, I paid another—the riding stable’s owner—to lead (and, in effect, wield the whip over) the grown workhorse under his control and take me around in a circle. The little workhorse had to follow behind and learn, too. By giving up an activity that costs me money and makes me unhappy, I can avoid one more instance of workhorses tearing into each other. I’m writing this here in the hope that the next person who agrees with me might cancel their ticket to a dolphin show, press the button to let someone through their residential complex’s gate, or, if they’re a frontline supervisor, put a stop to some task that makes people miserable.
I hope we can be the good workhorses—the ones who treat other workhorses kindly and help them shed the label.
I’ll go first: I’m never riding a horse again.